Line 41 (42): “The sea has its own complicated ways.” This really is a tricky range. The latest Greek regarding lines 41-42 seems to indicate, “Instance a lady is actually most importantly of all that way [the sea] in demeanor (orge); although water provides a different physical appearance (phye).” Thus Western, in his 1993 verse interpretation: “That’s what this woman’s including–when you look at the state of mind, / After all; there’s absolutely no resemblance within her appears!” Orgen stands early in range 42, prominently, inside the enjambment, implemented instantaneously of the phyen de; it certainly appear as if the brand new poet try drawing a contrast between inward aura and outward means. However for new poet in order to cover their malfunction of your own ocean-lady that have, “But a large system regarding salt liquids was in lieu of a lady within the physical appearance!” appears bizarrely inept.Several other means is to just take phye because a word for physis, “inwards nature,” and you may de- since a continuous in place of a comparing particle. Lloyd-Jones, following this path, explains alloien, “more,” just like the euphemistic to have “more in a beneficial sinister means,” and offer parallels; the guy translates, in his comments, “‘Plus the water provides a characteristics in lieu of that anything else,’ i.e., a characteristics which is sinister and you can uncanny” (73). My interpretation uses this approach the essential directly, even in the event because of the making de- untranslated I exit unlock the possibility that the newest poet try drawing a distinction amongst the sea-girl therefore the ocean. Get a hold of Renehan to own an introduction to recommended solutions (which includes removing the line). Renehan deletes the term orgen, hence “possibly originated since a polish or variation to help you phyen, passionate because of the v. eleven,” and you may inserts allot’ in advance of alloien (the phrase allot’ alloien, “switching from second to a higher,” is also included in range eleven). The sense of your own line will be that Lattimore’s translation: “This woman’s aura is just like the brand new sea’s / as the sea’s temper plus change day long.” Renehan’s membership of how text may have become corrupted is actually convincing, and he tends to be correct, however if they are Personally i think upset in Semonides. Renehan correctly points out one to (as opposed to received viewpoint) Semonides are “a more competent poet,” but really Renehan’s solution appears to myself a weak conclude to your sea-girl passing.
..” The sentences that i has translated given that “sex” contained in this range plus outlines 53 and you may 93 (91) are more colourful throughout the Greek; they all make use of the adjective aphrodisios, “relating to Aphrodite.” Lined up forty-eight the definition of is actually ergon aphrodision, “the job out of Aphrodite”; inside the 53, eunes aphrodisies, “the newest bed out-of Aphrodite”; from inside the 93 (91),aphrodisious logous, “aphrodisiac terminology.”
Range 53: “sex-crazed
Line forty-two: “she embraces …” The new verb made use of right here (dechomai) ‘s the regular verb for appealing otherwise finding an invitees. It is quite used in outlines 110 (107) (“render a decent acceptance”) and you will 121 (117) (“opened his doorways”) lower than. Cf. what are nordics women really likeed notes toward lines 20 (19) and you will 121-22 (117-18). The butt-woman was indiscriminate inside her hospitality.
A third strategy is always to emend the text
” Discover note on the web 48 more than on “intercourse.” My translation “crazed” comes after the brand new manuscript training alenes. Having a recommended etymology regarding the phrase (glossed of the Hesychius since mainomenos) come across Waanders. Western allows the conjecture adenes, “unaware, inexperienced.” See Western (1974) 178 with this and the after the line.
Outlines 53-54 (54): “climbs on board.” I realize West’s studying, peronta, “crossing over (as in an excellent ferry)” toward nautical metaphor. Other people read pareonta, “getting establish.” Lloyd-Jones, accompanied by Gerber (1979) 20, requires flood andra flooding pareonta to help you imply sometimes “whatever husband she’s got for the time being” or “any type of guy is with this lady,” and services the brand new people’s illness into weasel-female’s crappy smell. Verdenius (1977) 6 interprets flood andra flooding pareonta while the “Besucher” (guest).
Нет Ответов